Holiday Gift-Giving: Confessions from the Woman Wielding the Scotch Tape

by | Dec 2, 2025 | Humor

Image: SFD Media LLC

For every woman holding Christmas together with tape, receipts, and rage.

There are five love languages, or so we were told in the ‘90s by a man who probably thought a scented candle was foreplay. Yes, “words of affirmation” sound nice. “Quality time” sounds even better, especially if “quality” means “you fold the laundry while I watch Call the Midwife.”

But gift-giving? That’s the most emotionally charged of them all.

The Emotional Labor Olympics

It’s never just, “I thought you might like an air fryer.”

It’s emotional calculus.

It’s Olympic-level thoughtfulness.

It’s remembering that your sister-in-law collects salt pigs while your son’s girlfriend is “off gluten for her chakra alignment.”

This is where many women excel. We’re the unsung linguists of love in retail form.

Gift-giving is our love language, but it’s never about things. It’s about noticing all the details everyone misses while they’re busy scrolling.

And yet every holiday season, like clockwork, we’re reminded that apparently no one else speaks the same language.

While we curate identities, prevent disappointment, and obsess over the emotional significance of everything ever given, the people we love approach holiday gifting like a last-minute hostage negotiation at Walgreens.

Your Partner: The Hopeful Underachiever

They mean well. They truly do. Every December they confidently announce, “I really nailed it this time!”

They have not.

You unwrap something that vibrates (not in a fun way), fits no one in your home, or supports a hobby you don’t have. Last year it was a soil pH tester. “We have … plants?” they offered, beaming like they’d just solved marriage through photosynthesis.

You smile because you love them. And because they’re still the only partner who’s ever wrapped something instead of just handing over a Target bag.

But you’ll keep the damn thing. Because even after all these years, they’re still trying to speak your language.

Even if something’s been lost in translation.

Your Book Club: The Competitive Sentimentalists

It’s never been about the books. It’s about gossip with footnotes, emotional support with cheese pairings, and a competition to give the most devastatingly sarcastic-yet-accurate holiday gift.

A “Strong Female Character” mug.

A wine labeled “Pairs Beautifully with Resentment.”

A “Write Your Truth” journal that no one’s emotionally stable enough to fill out.

You’ll toast to “another great year of reading,” collectively forget what you read, and still show up next month.

Because it’s not just a book club.

It’s therapy with better snacks.

Your Son: Lost In Translation

He’s bright. He’s kind. He has your smile. And apparently, no recollection of who you are as a person.

He approaches gift-giving like a hostage negotiation: fast, panicked, and a cry for help. A blanket. A picture frame. A set of kitchen tongs clearly added to his cart while buying himself a new phone charger.

He gifts like he’s describing you to a sketch artist.

But when you see that single word—Love—scrawled on the card in his barely legible handwriting, you’ll cry anyway.

You know in his heart, he meant better.

He just forgot what it was.

Your “Wellness” Friend: Sage and Confusion

She’s one kombucha away from middle-aged enlightenment and assumes everyone wants to join her. She’ll give you something that looks like a rock and claim it “recalibrates your menopausal aura.” Or a salt lamp meant to “heal your sacral energy flow.”

You’ll politely say, “Oh, how thoughtful!” and then Google “What the hell is a moon bath?”

Will you ever use it? No.

Will you feel guilty when you don’t? Absolutely.

But it’s the thought that counts.

Even if it smells like burnt sage and confusion.

Your Daughter: The Gift Whisperer

Her gifts always say, “I know you better than you know yourself.”

Last year it was a serum that made you look like you’d slept eight hours for the first time since 1995. This year she’s sending you to a day spa and calling it, “the self-care that you deserve.”

You’ll love it.

You’ll hate how much you love it.

And you’ll wonder when, exactly, your daughter became the woman you’re still trying to be.

Your In-Laws: Emotional Landmines in Gift Bags

They’re masterful, charming, spot-on gift-givers who remember everyone’s favorite food, shirt size, or hobby.

Except yours.

Every box is an emotional landmine.

A cookbook titled Healthy Living for Women of a Certain Age. An enormous beige shawl that says, “We think you’re cold. Emotionally.” A candle that smells vaguely of disappointment and Kohl’s cash.

You’ll respond with, “Oh! You shouldn’t have!”

They know.

They truly shouldn’t have.

Your Millennial Niece: Handmade and a Little Judgy

She hands you something both handmade and suspiciously Etsy, wrapped in compostable paper that smells faintly of matcha. Inside is a handwritten note about gratitude and intergenerational bonding, or a bracelet that reminds her of “that special place we once got coffee.”

Somehow, she makes you feel both touched and like your Amazon Prime status personally murdered Santa Claus.

You’ll tear up. She’ll tear up. And then she’ll ask if you’ll record an Instagram Story about it.

And you will.

Because love is love, and also sometimes engagement.

Your Coworker: Unwrapping the Secret Santa

They’ve read one too many LinkedIn posts about “authenticity at work” and now think Secret Santa is the perfect arena to evaluate your psychological fitness. You were expecting peppermint bark. Instead you receive a mug engraved with “Let That Shit Go,” a bath bomb named Anxiety Attack, or a self-help book titled Emotional Regulation for Difficult Women that practically hisses when you touch it.

They’ll beam at you with an eerie, over-sincere smile and chirp, “I thought of you!” as you unwrap your “Breathe, Bitch” aromatherapy kit. You’ll fake laugh while silently asking yourself which meeting you cracked in. Because clearly, someone was taking notes.

Your Best Friend: The One Who Gets It

She knows your soul, your favorite yogurt, your bra size, and your ‘80s hair trauma. She doesn’t just give gifts—she gives permission.

To rest.

To rage.

To eat the good chocolate.

To wear the silk robe that makes you feel sexy when you want to escape a body you no longer recognize.

She makes every indulgence feel like an act of rebellion worth celebrating.

And because of her, you finally will.

And Then There’s You: The Woman Who Makes the Magic

You don’t just give gifts, you translate affection into experiences. Each gift is therapy, performance art, and a love letter that comes with a gift receipt.

It’s impressive.

It’s reflective.

And it’s exhausting.

But you do it anyway. Because somewhere between the Scotch tape and the 65th Target run, you’re reminded: It’s never been about stuff. It’s about fluency—in the details, the unspoken, the “I saw this and thought of how you still miss your mom at Christmas.”

It’s your love language—wrapped in tissue paper, tied with heart, and given as proof that you’re paying attention.

And you always will.

Unless someone gives you a week alone in a hotel with room service and silence.

Then all bets are off.

About the Author

Abby Heugel has spent more than 20 years as a writer and editor, working with clients like Meta, Instacart, Lyft, Google, BAND-AID, Neutrogena, Aveeno, and Johnson & Johnson—and now as a proud writer and editor at PROVOKED. When she’s not obsessing over the em dash, she can be found likely complaining about how they rearranged the grocery store again. You can also find Abby on Facebook and LinkedIn.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest

Submit a Pitch

Are you a bold, voicey writer with something provocative to say about being a woman 50+ today? We want fresh, unapologetic ideas that stir the pot, challenge stereotypes, and elevate the conversation for our community of vital, relevant women.

Submit a pitch here